AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

🔍 Read the full analysis: What Vanished Jobs Can Teach Us About AI’s Impact On Work on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

TL;DR

A November 2026 historical analysis from ThorstenMeyerAI.com compares elevator operators, typists and typesetters to examine how automation changes work. It cites economist James Bessen’s finding that only one of 271 occupations tracked from 1950 to 2010 largely disappeared because of automation, while warning that jobs centered on a single task can contract sharply.

A November 21 analysis from ThorstenMeyerAI.com uses the histories of elevator operators, typists and typesetters to assess what earlier automation may signal about AI and employment. Its central finding is that machines have more often taken over parts of jobs than eliminated entire occupations—though work built around a narrow, repeatable task can shrink quickly.

The analysis draws on economist James Bessen’s 2016 study of 271 detailed occupations recorded in the 1950 U.S. census and followed through 2010. Bessen found that only one occupation in that group—elevator operator—largely disappeared because of automation. Other occupations vanished for different reasons, including reduced demand or the obsolescence of the technology they served. Bessen described the more common pattern as “partial automation”: machines assumed tasks while jobs changed or continued.

The history of elevator operators illustrates how adoption can take time. The U.S. census counted about 97,000 operators in 1950, after decades of growth in the occupation. Otis’s company history says it introduced automatic elevators with recorded voices while attendants were still present, in part to help passengers adjust. In 1950, an Otis automatic system without attendants opened in a Dallas office building. Census counts later fell to about 77,000 in 1960 and 37,000 in 1970.

The source also describes a sharper decline in typing work after word processors and personal computers spread. In 1988, the Bureau of Labor Statistics counted 985,000 word processors and typists. The analysis says official forecasters expected a 6% decline by 2000, but the actual decline was 51%. It reports about 40,400 people in the occupation in 2025. These figures describe a particular occupational category; they do not, on their own, show how many affected workers left employment or moved into other roles.

At a glance
analysisWhen: Published November 21, 2026; U.S. emplo…
The developmentA November 21, 2026, essay uses three past occupations to examine what historical job losses can—and cannot—tell us about AI’s effects on work.
Thorsten Meyer AI
Work After Work · Ep. 19

Infographic 01 · The number to remember

The one job automation wiped out

Elevator operators rose with the skyscrapers and fell with the automatic elevator. Of 271 occupations in the 1950 census, it is the only one that automation largely wiped out.

97,000US elevator operators in 1950, the peak (census)
37,000in 1970 (census)
1 of 271occupations of the 1950 census that automation largely wiped out by 2010: this one (Bessen)
24,700US elevator installer and repairer jobs in 2025 (BLS), median pay $109,910

US elevator operators · census · thousands

  • 190013k
  • 191025k
  • 192041k
  • 193068k
  • 194087k
  • 1950the peak97k
  • 196077k
  • 197037k

Story vs. evidence

  • Documented (TIME, 8 Oct 1945): 16,600 elevator operators and building workers on strike in 2,100 Manhattan buildings for five and a half days.
  • Documented (Otis, company account): 1948 a recorded voice to help passengers trust automatic elevators; 1950 the first building with Otis high-speed, no-operator elevators (Dallas).
  • Not documented: that the strike made owners switch to automatic elevators. A popular story; no source we found shows it.

Census figures: economically active persons 14 and over, each census in its own classification (1950 in the 1950 classification). Today the BLS publishes no separate count of elevator operators; installers and repairers are a different occupation.

Sources: US Census Bureau, Historical Statistics of the United States (1975), series D 233-682 (row D 587); J. Bessen, How Computer Automation Affects Occupations (2016); TIME, 8 Oct 1945; Otis company history; BLS Employment Projections 2025-35 (27 Aug 2026).
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI

Why Task-Focused Jobs Face Greater Risk

The historical comparison offers a useful distinction for workers and employers weighing AI’s effects: automating tasks is not the same as eliminating a job. A tool may reduce time spent on routine work, change a role’s duties or raise demand for other skills without making the occupation disappear. But if a job is built mainly around a task that technology can perform, there may be fewer remaining duties to support the same number of positions.

The analysis connects that distinction to a current labor-market forecast. It says that in August 2026 the BLS projected office and administrative support occupations to shrink faster than any other major occupational group by 2035, partly because of AI tools. The group still accounts for about one in nine U.S. jobs, according to the source. A projected decline is not a count of jobs already lost, and the source does not establish how much of any future change will be caused by AI rather than other factors. Still, the forecast puts a large category of work in focus.

For readers, the lesson is not that AI will repeat the past exactly. Instead, the examples show why the effects depend on the tasks in a job, how quickly organizations adopt new tools, and whether workers can move into work that complements them. The evidence also cautions against treating every task exposed to automation as proof that an entire occupation is about to vanish.

Products Worth Considering

LG UltraGear 34-Inch Curved QHD Gaming Monitor, 160Hz, FreeSync Premium

LG UltraGear 34-Inch Curved QHD Gaming Monitor, 160Hz, FreeSync Premium

DJI Mic 3 Wireless Microphone (2 Transmitters, 1 Receiver, Charging Case)

DJI Mic 3 Wireless Microphone (2 Transmitters, 1 Receiver, Charging Case)

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

From Elevator Cars to Typing Pools

The elevator operator’s decline was gradual, even after automatic systems became available. The source recounts a 1945 strike in which TIME magazine reported that 16,600 elevator operators and other building workers walked out across 2,100 buildings in Manhattan. The five-and-a-half-day strike concerned a wage ruling. Union leader David Sullivan later said, “We were hurting our best friends—the garment workers,” referring to the disruption for people working in the district.

The strike is often retold as the moment building owners chose automatic elevators. But the source says it found no document showing that the strike caused the shift. The connection may be part of the story, but it should not be stated as established fact. The documented employment decline and the spread of automatic elevators are evidence of change; they do not prove that one event triggered it.

Typing offers a different example of how technology can first create and then reshape work. The typewriter helped expand office employment: the source cites a rise from 134,000 stenographers, typists and secretaries in 1900 to 3.9 million in 1970. Later, word processors and personal computers altered the tasks and staffing needs of offices. In printing, the source says German typesetters used a three-week strike in 1978 to defend skilled workers’ control of text design. By 1998, their apprenticeship had been merged into a new media-design trade. The examples show different paths—decline, adaptation and occupational change—rather than one automatic outcome.

What History Cannot Prove About AI

Past employment patterns cannot establish how many jobs AI will eliminate, which occupations will be affected most, or how quickly changes will occur. The source cites a BLS projection for office and administrative support through 2035, but it does not provide a breakdown of expected losses attributable specifically to AI, nor does a projection confirm that those losses have happened.

The strike’s relationship to the adoption of automatic elevators also remains unproven in the source’s account. For typing, the figures chart a steep occupational decline, but they do not trace individual workers’ later employment or separate the effects of computers from other workplace changes. The source’s historical comparisons can frame questions about AI; they cannot answer them on their own.

Watch Employment and Task Changes

The next evidence will come from how employers deploy AI and how employment changes across occupations, not from historical analogy alone. Readers can compare future BLS updates with current forecasts, while looking for data that distinguish actual job counts from projections and show changes in tasks, wages and worker movement between roles. The source does not identify a single upcoming study or milestone that will settle AI’s employment effects.

For now, the historical record supports a measured conclusion: automation has often changed what workers do rather than removing whole occupations, but that pattern offers no guarantee for jobs concentrated around tasks that new tools can perform. Whether AI produces broad job contraction, altered roles or both remains an open question.

Key Questions

What is the main finding about automation and vanished jobs?

Economist James Bessen’s study, as described in the source, found that one of 271 occupations tracked from 1950 to 2010 largely disappeared because of automation: elevator operator. The analysis says automation more often took over tasks than entire jobs.

Did the 1945 elevator strike cause automatic elevators to replace operators?

The source says the strike is often linked to that change, but it found no document proving the strike caused the switch. The connection remains a popular account, not an established fact in the material provided.

What does the source say about AI and office jobs?

It reports that the BLS projected office and administrative support to be the fastest-shrinking major occupational group by 2035, partly because of AI tools. That is a forecast, not a tally of jobs already lost to AI.

Do the examples predict which jobs AI will eliminate?

No. The examples suggest that jobs centered on automatable tasks may be more exposed, but past cases cannot determine which occupations AI will affect or the scale and timing of future employment changes.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

You May Also Like

2026’S Most Influential AI Breakthroughs: A Top 10 Overview

A comprehensive overview of the most significant AI innovations of 2026, highlighting confirmed advances and their impact on technology and society.

Unlocking AI Potential: Meta Introduces Muse Spark 1.2

Meta releases Muse Spark 1.2, a coding-focused AI model paired with Muse Code agent, emphasizing co-training and long-horizon task handling.

The Ultimate Guide To Security Layers For AI Agent Infrastructure

A new security proxy for MCP servers introduces per-tool allowlists, identity verification, and audit logs to enhance AI agent infrastructure security.

Apple Intelligence in 2025: On‑Device Vs Private Cloud Compute

Meta description: “Many wonder how Apple’s 2025 AI balances on-device power with private cloud compute—discover how this evolution reshapes your digital world.