📊 Full opportunity report: Phase 1 synthesis. What the four sectors crystallize. on ThorstenMeyerAI.com — validation score, market gap, and execution plan.

TL;DR

Phase 1 of the Post-Labor Transition Atlas confirms four structurally distinct displacement patterns across key sectors, driven by sectoral characteristics. This sets the foundation for targeted policy responses starting in mid-2026.

Empirical analysis confirms that four key sectors—software engineering, professional services, customer service/BPO, and creative industries—exhibit distinct AI-driven labor displacement patterns, establishing a foundational understanding for policy responses.

Research from Thorsten Meyer’s Post-Labor Transition Atlas has identified four sector-specific patterns of labor displacement driven by AI, each shaped by unique sectoral characteristics. These patterns include cohort-bifurcation in software engineering, sub-sector heterogeneity in professional services, operational-scale displacement in BPO, and the middle-squeeze phenomenon in creative industries.

The analysis, based on comprehensive sector forensics, confirms that the heterogeneity observed is a structural signature rather than a deviation, supporting the interpretation that transition effects are heterogeneous and sector-dependent. This empirical foundation completes Phase 1 of the Atlas, setting the stage for policy responses scheduled to begin in mid-2026, aligned with the EU AI Act enforcement window.

Phase 1 Synthesis · What the Four Sectors Crystallize.
DISPATCH / MAY 2026 ATLAS · POST-LABOR TRANSITION · PHASE 1 SYNTHESIS · CLOSING BRACKET
▲ Atlas Essay 06 Phase 1 Synthesis · Closing Bracket · May 2026
Atlas Essay 06 · Phase 1 Synthesis · What the Four Sectors Crystallize

Phase 1 synthesis.
What the four
sectors crystallize.

Four sector forensics shipped · four distinct displacement patterns · five attribution factors · four-interpretations confirmation · pipeline horizons 2027-2035+. The empirical-evidence foundation Phase 1 produces — and the structural bridge to Phase 2 (jurisdictional policy responses · July-August 2026).

This is Atlas Essay 06 — the integrative synthesis closing Phase 1’s empirical-evidence sector-forensic foundation before Phase 2 begins. Phase 1 has produced an empirical-evidence foundation that is structurally complete — and the cross-sector integrative finding is that “AI-driven labor displacement” is not a single phenomenon but a family of structurally distinct patterns whose axes are determined by sectoral characteristics. Pattern 1 cohort-bifurcation (Essay 02 · software engineering · career-stage axis). Pattern 2 sub-sector heterogeneity (Essay 03 · professional services · industry-vertical axis). Pattern 3 operational-scale displacement (Essay 04 · BPO · geographic+operational axis). Pattern 4 creative-skill-spectrum bifurcation (Essay 05 · creative industries · creative-skill-spectrum axis). Interpretation 2 from Essay 01 — transition arriving slowly with heterogeneous effects — is empirically dominant across all four sectors. The heterogeneity itself is the structural signature, not a deviation from it.

▲ The structural editorial finding · Phase 1 empirical foundation complete
Phase 1 has produced empirical evidence for four structurally distinct displacement patterns operating across four structurally distinct axes determined by sectoral characteristics. “AI-driven labor displacement” is not a single phenomenon — it is a family of patterns. The cohort-bifurcation hypothesis from Essay 02 is operationally important but not universal. Interpretation 2 is empirically dominant across all four sectors. The heterogeneity itself is the structural signature.
— atlas essay 06 · phase 1 synthesis · what the four sectors crystallize · may 2026 · phase 1 closing bracket
4 / 4
Sector forensics shipped · structurally distinct displacement patterns · Phase 1 empirical foundation complete
Cohort-bifurcation + sub-sector heterogeneity + operational-scale + creative-skill-spectrum · four axes determined by sectoral characteristics
5 / 4
Attribution factors crystallized across four sectors · three universal + two sector-specific
Macroeconomic + AI-tool + cohort-specific universal · pyramid-model (professional services) + substitutable-output (creative) sector-specific
I2
Interpretation 2 empirically dominant across all four sector forensics · heterogeneity itself is the structural signature
Transition arriving slowly with heterogeneous effects · I3 strongest in BPO · I1 + I4 partial fits · Atlas framework holds all four simultaneously
12essays
Atlas essays remaining after Phase 1 · Phase 2 (5) + Phase 3 (5) + Phase 4 (2) · July-November 2026
Phase 2 jurisdictional policy responses · aligned with August 2 EU AI Act enforcement window · Phases 3-4 structural alternatives + synthesis
PHASE 1 COMPLETE 4 SECTOR FORENSICS · 4 DISTINCT PATTERNS · 5 ATTRIBUTION FACTORS · 4-INTERPRETATIONS CONFIRMATION PATTERN 01 COHORT-BIFURCATION · SOFTWARE ENGINEERING · CAREER-STAGE AXIS · 40% JUNIOR DROP · 57/43 AUG/AUTO PATTERN 02 SUB-SECTOR HETEROGENEITY · PROFESSIONAL SERVICES · INDUSTRY-VERTICAL AXIS · KPMG -29% TO MCKINSEY +12% PATTERN 03 OPERATIONAL-SCALE · BPO · GEOGRAPHIC+OPERATIONAL AXIS · 8M WORKERS · KLARNA CANONICAL CASE PATTERN 04 CREATIVE-SKILL-SPECTRUM · CREATIVE INDUSTRIES · MIDDLE SQUEEZE · -33% GRAPHIC DESIGN · +340% AI COLLAB PIPELINE HORIZONS SOFTWARE 2027-2029 · BPO 2028-2030 · PROFESSIONAL SERVICES 2030-2035+ · CREATIVE ONGOING PHASE 2 BRIDGE JURISDICTIONAL POLICY RESPONSES JULY-AUGUST 2026 · ALIGNED WITH EU AI ACT ENFORCEMENT
The four-pattern integration · Phase 1 structural finding

Four patterns. Four axes.

Phase 1’s four sector forensics produce empirical evidence for four structurally distinct displacement patterns operating across four structurally distinct axes determined by sectoral characteristics. This is what Phase 1 contributes to the post-labor economics discourse — the analytical-discipline framework that holds multiple patterns simultaneously.

Four-pattern integration · the empirical-evidence foundation crystallized
Sectors with stratified training pyramids produce cohort-bifurcation patterns. Sectors with operational-scale workforces produce geographic-concentration patterns. Sectors with substitutable-output spectrums produce skill-spectrum bifurcation patterns. The heterogeneity itself is the structural signature.
▲ Pattern 01 · Essay 02
Cohort-bifurcation
Software engineering · canonical case
Junior cohort displaced · senior augmented · pipeline collapsing 2027-2029. Within-sector cohort stratification · 57/43 augmentation/automation Anthropic Economic Index · METR senior+codebase finding · ~40% junior hiring drop.
Career-stage
axis
▲ Pattern 02 · Essay 03
Sub-sector heterogeneity
White-collar professional services
Cohort-bifurcation fragmented across four sub-sectors. Big 4 -29% to -6% · Goldman+Morgan Stanley 2/3 entry-level · McKinsey +12% contra-signal · legal lagging at NALP 93.4%. Pyramid-model pressure as fourth factor · 5-10yr pipeline.
Industry-vertical
axis
▲ Pattern 03 · Essay 04
Operational-scale displacement
Customer service + BPO
Geographic concentration · workforce-wide horizontal pressure · hybrid-model emergence from failure. 8M India+Philippines workers · Oracle -12K + TCS -12K · Klarna canonical case launch→scaling→reversal→hybrid · McKinsey 400M global.
Geographic +
operational axis
▲ Pattern 04 · Essay 05
Creative-skill-spectrum bifurcation
Creative industries · middle squeeze
Top augments · commodity substitutes · middle compresses. -33% graphic design postings · +340% AI-collaboration · 5 sub-fields converge on bifurcation · substitutable-output axis as fifth attribution factor · skill-tier within same workforce.
Creative-skill-
spectrum axis
The five-factor attribution synthesis · universal vs sector-specific
Software Testing with Generative AI

Software Testing with Generative AI

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Five factors. Sector-specific rigor.

The analytical-decomposition crystallization Phase 1 produces. Five attribution factors identified across four sectors — three universal plus two sector-specific. The Atlas framework operates on sector-specific attribution rigor rather than universal-displacement-driver claims.

Five-factor attribution · universal + sector-specific decomposition
Each sector has its own attribution profile — three universal factors plus zero, one, or two sector-specific factors. Structurally consequential for Phase 2’s policy-response analysis. Universal factors require universal policy responses; sector-specific factors require sector-specific responses.
01Macro
Macroeconomic · 2023-2024 interest rate hikes · capital crunch · cost-cutting pressure
Empirically dominant in driving initial hiring freezes across all four sectors. Would have produced some hiring decline even without AI tool maturation. Universal across software engineering, professional services, BPO, creative industries.
Universal
02AI
AI-tool maturation · operational substitutability crossed threshold 2023-2025
Sector-specific tool stacks · universal mechanism. SWE: Copilot/Cursor/Claude Code. Pro services: Harvey/Casetext/IndexGPT/Big 4 platforms. BPO: enterprise chatbots/Klarna OpenAI. Creative: Midjourney/Canva/Sora/Suno/DeepL.
Universal
03Cohort
Cohort-specific compounding · entry-level positions structurally most exposed
Compounds with other factors. Operationally most visible in SWE + professional services where cohort-bifurcation dominates. Structurally weaker in BPO (horizontal pressure) and creative (skill-tier axis dominates).
Universal
04Pyramid
Pyramid-model pressure · professional services sector-specific
Pre-existing structural erosion AI accelerates rather than initiates. Large junior cohorts billing routine work under senior supervision · client efficiency pressure for over a decade · 5-10yr partner-track pipeline horizon mechanism. Essay 03 specific.
Pro
services
05Output
Substitutable-output axis · creative industries sector-specific
“Good enough” threshold varies dramatically across creative-output spectrum. Low-threshold commodity easily AI-achievable · high-threshold signature requires creative judgment AI cannot reliably reproduce · middle-threshold commercial faces reliability gaps creating the squeeze. Essay 05 specific.
Creative
The four-interpretations confirmation · which sectors privilege which
MUCAR 892BT AI-Assisted Bidirectional Scan Tool, Full System OBD2 Scanner, Bi-Directional OBD2 Scanner Diagnostic Tool,ECU Coding, 35 Services, FCA Autoauth, CANFD and DOIP, Free Lifetime Upgrade

MUCAR 892BT AI-Assisted Bidirectional Scan Tool, Full System OBD2 Scanner, Bi-Directional OBD2 Scanner Diagnostic Tool,ECU Coding, 35 Services, FCA Autoauth, CANFD and DOIP, Free Lifetime Upgrade

【Powerful Performance】: OBD2 scanner, featuring an 8-inch ultra-large display, the MUCAR 892BT runs on Android 10 with a…

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Four interpretations. Phase 1 confirmation.

Essay 01 introduced four structural interpretations the framework holds simultaneously. Phase 1’s four sector forensics empirically test which interpretation each sector privileges. The cross-sector pattern crystallizes which interpretations are dominant in which sectoral contexts.

Four-interpretations confirmation matrix · cross-sector empirical test
The Atlas framework holds all four interpretations simultaneously. Phase 1’s empirical evidence supports the editorial-discipline framing — holding multiple interpretations is what makes the empirical base genuinely usable.
I2Dominant
Transition arriving slowly with heterogeneous effects
Empirically dominant across all four sector forensics. SWE cohort-bifurcation + pro services sub-sector heterogeneity + BPO operational-scale + creative middle squeeze. The heterogeneity itself is the structural signature.
All 4
sectors
I3Strong
Transition arriving fast with structural alternatives unrecognized
Empirically strongest in BPO. 8M workers · Oracle -12K + TCS -12K · IT-BPM 2028 targets requiring revision · McKinsey 400M global · structural alternatives not yet operationally deployed at scale in affected geographies.
BPO
specific
I4Partial
Transition arriving fast with structural alternatives operationally available
Operational-credibility support but not deployment-at-scale. Klarna hybrid equilibrium · Stocksy United platform cooperatives · Nordic social-protection · Finland UBI retrospective · Gulf states sovereign-wealth model. Phase 3 documents structural alternatives.
Multi-
sector
I1Weak
Transition not arriving at scale
Partially confirmed at aggregate-sector level only. SWE aggregate sector employment rising · legal NALP 93.4% aggregate signal · but cohort-specific and tier-specific displacement evidence in every sector is substantial. Discourse should not dismiss but also not over-rely.
Aggregate
only
The pipeline-horizon synthesis · 2027 → 2035+
Express Schedule Free Employee Scheduling Software [PC/Mac Download]

Express Schedule Free Employee Scheduling Software [PC/Mac Download]

Simple shift planning via an easy drag & drop interface

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Four horizons. 2027-2035+.

The temporal-integration crystallization Phase 1 produces. Pipeline problems across the four sectors operate on different horizons — but they share the structural mechanism of cohort-bifurcation second-order effects. The forward-looking landscape Phase 4 will integrate.

Pipeline-horizon synthesis · cross-sector temporal integration
All four sectors face structural second-order effects. Juniors not hired today = mid-levels missing tomorrow · pipeline gaps, reskilling pressures, training-system reconfiguration on sector-specific time horizons.
2027-29
Software engineering · mid-level engineer gap · cohort-bifurcation second-order effect
2-5 year horizon · junior-to-mid training cycle. Juniors not hired 2024-2026 = mid-levels missing 2027-2029. The discourse underweights this second-order effect.
Shortest
horizon
2028-30
Customer service + BPO · 2030 reckoning · workforce-wide pressure
IT-BPM 2028 targets requiring revision · McKinsey 400M global by 2030. Geographic concentration in India + Philippines · structural workforce-wide pressure not cohort-specific.
Geographic
concentration
2030-35+
Professional services · partner-track / equity-track gap · pyramid-model erosion
5-10 year horizon · associate-to-partner training cycle. Juniors not hired today = senior associates missing 2030-2034 = new partners missing 2032-2035+. Longest horizon · slower manifestation.
Longest
horizon
Ongoing
Creative industries · middle-tier reskilling · platform-cooperative emergence
Continuous structural compression. Middle-tier reskilling timeline 2-4 years · platform-cooperative emergence horizon uncertain · substitutable-output axis operates on ongoing rather than cyclical timeline.
Ongoing
compression
Phase 1 → Phase 2 bridge · what comes next · 12 essays remaining
HOW TO CREATE DIGITAL PRODUCTS WITH GROK 4 FOR BEGINNERS: A Step-by-Step Guide to Making Money From Creating And Selling AI Products Without Tech Knowledge

HOW TO CREATE DIGITAL PRODUCTS WITH GROK 4 FOR BEGINNERS: A Step-by-Step Guide to Making Money From Creating And Selling AI Products Without Tech Knowledge

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Bridge to Phase 2. July 2026.

The structural-discipline crystallization Phase 1 produces. Phase 1’s empirical-evidence foundation is structurally complete. Phase 2 begins July-August 2026 with the jurisdictional policy-response analysis operationally aligned with the August 2 EU AI Act enforcement window.

Phase 1 → Phase 2 bridge · the Atlas continues through November 2026
Phase 1 (May-June 2026) is the empirical-evidence foundation. Phase 2 (July-August 2026) extends the framework to jurisdictional policy responses. Phase 3 (September-October 2026) extends to structural alternatives. Phase 4 (November 2026) crystallizes the integrative synthesis.
▲ Phase 1 · Complete
Empirical evidence
6shipped
May-Jun 2026
▲ Phase 2 · Next
Policy responses
5pieces
Jul-Aug 2026
EU AI Act window
▲ Phase 3 · Pending
Structural alternatives
5pieces
Sep-Oct 2026
▲ Phase 4 · Closing
Synthesis + close
2pieces
Nov 2026
full closing bracket

Phase 1’s four sector forensics produce empirical evidence for four structurally distinct displacement patterns operating across four structurally distinct axes determined by sectoral characteristics. “AI-driven labor displacement” is not a single phenomenon — it is a family of patterns. The cohort-bifurcation hypothesis from Essay 02 is operationally important but not universal. Interpretation 2 — transition arriving slowly with heterogeneous effects — is empirically dominant across all four sectors. The heterogeneity itself is the structural signature, not a deviation from it. This is the analytical-discipline framework Phase 1 contributes to the post-labor economics discourse — and the empirical foundation Phases 2-4 operate on.

— Atlas Essay 06 · Phase 1 synthesis · what the four sectors crystallize · the empirical-evidence foundation closing-bracket · May 2026
Source dossier · the Phase 1 sector-forensic integration · Essays 01-05
  • Atlas Essay 01 · The Atlas opening · what the framework is · four-dimension architecture · six chromatic registers · four structural interpretations · synthesis-deep register
  • Atlas Essay 02 · Software engineering · the canonical case · Pattern 1 cohort-bifurcation · career-stage axis · empirical-clay register · ~40% junior drop · 57/43 augmentation/automation · METR senior+codebase · 2027-2029 mid-level pipeline gap
  • Atlas Essay 03 · White-collar professional services · the Tier 1 displacement · Pattern 2 sub-sector heterogeneity · industry-vertical axis · labor-rose register · KPMG -29% / Deloitte -18% / EY -11% / PwC -6% · Goldman + Morgan Stanley 2/3 entry-level · McKinsey +12% contra-signal · 5-10yr pipeline · pyramid-model pressure
  • Atlas Essay 04 · Customer service + BPO · the operational-scale displacement · Pattern 3 operational-scale · geographic+operational axis · empirical-clay register · 8M India + Philippines · Oracle -12K + TCS -12K · India IT +17 net employees · Klarna canonical case · hybrid equilibrium · McKinsey 400M global
  • Atlas Essay 05 · Creative industries · the bifurcated reality · Pattern 4 creative-skill-spectrum · creative-skill-spectrum axis · labor-rose register · -33% graphic design · +340% AI-collaboration · 5 sub-fields converge · substitutable-output axis · middle squeeze
  • This piece · Atlas Essay 06 · Phase 1 synthesis · what the four sectors crystallize · synthesis-deep register
  • Atlas framework architecture · 4 dimensions · 6 chromatic registers · 4 structural interpretations · 18 essays · 4 phases · May-November 2026
  • Phase 1 deliverables shipped · 6 essays + 6 infographics + 6 featured + 6 OG = 24 deliverables · empirical-evidence foundation structurally complete
  • The four-pattern integration · cohort-bifurcation + sub-sector heterogeneity + operational-scale + creative-skill-spectrum bifurcation
  • The four structurally distinct axes · career-stage + industry-vertical + geographic+operational + creative-skill-spectrum
  • The five-factor attribution synthesis · 3 universal (macroeconomic + AI-tool maturation + cohort-specific compounding) + 2 sector-specific (pyramid-model · substitutable-output)
  • The four-interpretations confirmation · I2 empirically dominant across all 4 sectors · I3 strongest in BPO · I1 + I4 partial fits · framework holds all 4 simultaneously
  • Pipeline-horizon synthesis · SWE 2027-2029 · BPO 2028-2030 · pro services 2030-2035+ · creative ongoing · 4 sectors face structural second-order effects on sector-specific time horizons
  • The structural editorial finding · “AI-driven labor displacement” is a family of structurally distinct patterns, not a single phenomenon · the heterogeneity itself is the structural signature
  • Phase 1 → Phase 2 bridge · jurisdictional policy responses · July-August 2026 · operationally aligned with August 2 EU AI Act enforcement window
  • Phase 2 scope · 5 essays · US response · EU response · Nordic + UK response · Asian response divergence · Gulf states sovereign-wealth model + Phase 2 synthesis
  • Phase 3 scope · 5 essays · broad-based capital ownership · platform cooperatives · taxation reforms · shorter working week · job guarantee + Phase 3 synthesis
  • Phase 4 scope · 2 essays · post-labor economics synthesis + closing-bracket retrospective
  • The Atlas contribution to the post-labor discourse · analytical-discipline framework that holds multiple patterns + multiple factors + multiple interpretations simultaneously
  • The structural-pattern observation · sectoral characteristics determine which displacement axis dominates · sectors with stratified training pyramids produce cohort-bifurcation · sectors with operational-scale workforces produce geographic-concentration · sectors with substitutable-output spectrums produce skill-spectrum bifurcation
  • Cumulative editorial output through May 2026 · Clark franchise 9 pieces · Software security franchise 8 pieces · European sovereign-LLM track 11 pieces (closed) · Post-Labor Transition Atlas Phase 1 6 pieces · 34 pieces total · 136 deliverables
Colophon · Atlas Essay 06 · Phase 1 Synthesis · Closing Bracket

Set in Source Serif 4 (display), EB Garamond (essay body), IBM Plex Sans & IBM Plex Mono. Post-Labor Transition Atlas · Phase 1 synthesis · the integrative crystallization closing the empirical-evidence sector-forensic foundation. Four sector forensics. Four distinct displacement patterns. Five attribution factors. Four-interpretations confirmation. Pipeline horizons 2027-2035+. Phase 1 empirical foundation structurally complete. Synthesis-deep dominant register · all five other chromatic registers (labor-rose · empirical-clay · alternative-sage · transition-bronze · structural-slate) brought back as the patterns/factors/interpretations they represent · editorial-continuity register matching Essay 01 opening bracket. Free to embed with attribution.

thorstenmeyerai.com

Atlas Essay 06 · Phase 1 synthesis · the closing bracket · May 2026

4 PATTERNS · 5 FACTORS · 4 INTERPRETATIONS · 2027-2035+ HORIZONS · PHASE 2 BEGINS JULY 2026

Implications of Sector-Specific Displacement Patterns

This confirmation of four distinct displacement patterns underscores that AI-driven labor impacts are not uniform but sector-specific, necessitating tailored policy measures. Understanding these patterns helps policymakers anticipate workforce shifts and design interventions that address unique sectoral challenges, improving the effectiveness of labor transition strategies.

Foundations of Sectoral Displacement Analysis

The Post-Labor Transition Atlas, initiated in early 2026, has systematically analyzed labor displacement across multiple sectors using a four-dimension architecture. Previous essays established the theoretical framework, identifying key interpretative axes and structural signatures. The current phase synthesizes empirical findings, confirming four distinct patterns of displacement aligned with sectoral characteristics, which are critical for informed policy-making.

“The four sector forensics empirically confirm that AI-driven labor displacement manifests as structurally distinct patterns, each driven by specific sectoral characteristics.”

— Thorsten Meyer

Unconfirmed Aspects of Sectoral Displacement Patterns

While the four patterns are empirically confirmed, the precise long-term evolution of each pattern, especially in response to policy interventions, remains uncertain. The extent to which sector-specific displacement effects will intensify or diminish over time is still under investigation.

Transition to Policy-Oriented Phase in Mid-2026

Beginning in July-August 2026, Phase 2 will activate, focusing on jurisdictional policy responses aligned with the EU AI Act enforcement window. This phase will test the effectiveness of tailored interventions based on the sector-specific displacement patterns identified in Phase 1, with ongoing monitoring and refinement.

Key Questions

What are the four sectors analyzed in the study?

The four sectors are software engineering, professional services (including accounting, consulting, legal), customer service/BPO, and creative industries.

What are the main displacement patterns identified?

The patterns include cohort-bifurcation in software engineering, sub-sector heterogeneity in professional services, operational-scale displacement in BPO, and middle-squeeze in creative industries.

How does this research influence policy-making?

It provides a validated empirical foundation showing sector-specific impacts, enabling policymakers to design targeted interventions aligned with each sector’s displacement pattern.

Is the heterogeneity in displacement effects a temporary or permanent feature?

The current analysis confirms it as a structural signature, but the long-term persistence and evolution depend on future policy and technological developments, which are still being studied.

When will policy responses based on this analysis be implemented?

Policy responses are scheduled to begin in July-August 2026, coinciding with the EU AI Act enforcement window.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

You May Also Like

Generative AI on Mobile GPUs: Benchmarking the Latest Chips

Keen to see how the latest mobile GPUs excel in generative AI benchmarks and what this means for the future of AI on the go?

Ultrasonic Vs Optical Fingerprint Sensors

An in-depth comparison of ultrasonic and optical fingerprint sensors reveals key differences that could impact your device security and usability.

Mini-LED TVs Have More Going for Them Than People Realize

Beneath their sleek design, Mini-LED TVs offer hidden benefits that could change your viewing experience—find out what you’re missing.

Why Some Apps Block Screenshots: DRM, Flags, and Privacy

Know why certain apps block screenshots through DRM, flags, and privacy features to protect sensitive content and what it means for users.